Broodstock Health: Mitigating Stress Effects Prior to Spawning
By
Jim Powell, PhD, R.P. Bio
Reprinted Courtesy of
Northern Aquaculture, July 2002
.
Review of the stress response
When a fish perceives an insult to
health whether it is a physical, environmental or physiological insult,
it responds first with an adrenergic (flight of fight) response, and a
longer, sustained response characterized by an increase in the stress
hormone, cortisol. The first response gives a burst of adrenalin that
increases blood sugar, speeds the passage of sugar into cells and shuts
down things like digestion. Other things like respiration rate and heart
rate also increase to aid in flight or fight. The longer term response,
the cortisol response, puts all non-essential services such as growth,
immune response and reproduction on hold while the insult is either
dealt with or passes. As is apparent, neither situation contributes to a
happy fish, especially when trying to build eggs.
Endocrine profiles of GtH
The timing of when this insult or stress occurs in a broodstock’s life
is important. From the above, a stress-inducing event will arrest
reproduction. There are two major stages of maturation: vitellogenesis
and gamete maturation (ovulation). Each stage is governed by a distinct
gonadotropin: GtH I for vitellogenesis and GtH II for maturation. As
Figure 1 implies, the vitellogenic stage is much longer in duration than
the maturation stage. Both stages have critical periods where stress can
make a fool of the most astute Broodstock Manager.
Figure 1: Stylized representation
of GtH profiles during maturation. Vitellogenesis is controlled
by GtH-I and the predominant steroid is estradiol. Egg
maturation and ovulation is influenced by GtH-II and
testosterone (11-KT) and progesterone (DOHP).

|
Results of early stress
Growth is an easy thing to start and stop. If the stress is minor, of
small duration or impact, then growth is temporarily halted. Growth is
soon back to normal once things improve. Not so with vitellogenesis.
This is a big machine that involves several internal organs. Once in
motion, there is a momentum that is hard to maintain. So, if a stressor
results in stalling or slowing vitellogenesis, egg number is sacrificed.
As a rule of thumb, an early stressor, one that occurs before the peak
in vitellogenesis, results in a decrease in egg number: fecundity. The
energy that would normally go to building eggs from that great
broodstock diet now goes towards building a big fish. The result is a
beautiful fish, but with fewer eggs than predicted. This throws egg
number calculations for a loop because the fish are huge, but bear
proportionally fewer number of eggs.
Stressors that occur after the peak in vitellogenesis have a different
effect on the fish. Late stress forces the fish to shut down further
vitellogenesis resulting in the resorption or abandonment of some of the
eggs. This is because there is not enough vitellogenin (yolk) to go
around due to an interruption of supply. Again, critical functions are
put on hold to ensure survival of the whole organism; egg size,
performance and ultimately number are sacrificed to ensure the survival
of the fish.
So much for stress during vitellogenesis. Stressors that occur during
the short maturation, usually one month prior to spawning of the first
fish, cause different responses in maturing fish. These effects range
from males that dry up or females that produce early, but poor quality
eggs. Males that are thought to be
running, but one week later have gone silver or produce nothing are in
this category as are females that give eggs early but have variable
quality.
The effect of a late stress can be of three choices for a female fish:
1) the stress is of little effect and things proceed normally, 2)
ovulation is advanced and the eggs ‘ditched’, or 3) ovulation is delayed
or aborted.
Stress events at spawning are of little consequence to fish or egg
performance. Events that occur late in the season or at spawning appear
not to effect egg survival. The most important period to influence
performance appears to be during the GtH I to GtH II shift when the GtHs
change as do the steroids that control vitellogenesis or maturation of
the gametes,
Stress-inducing events
Routine husbandry of broodstock is full of stress-inducing events.
Early stressful events include sorting and selection, splitting pens,
and transporting. Environmental stressors such as temperature changes,
water quality issues or holding conditions also can lead to a stress
response in the fish. And don’t forget the big-eyed, furry stressors
with the high cuddle quotient, seals: otters and sea lions. In all of
these events, timing, duration and recovery are essential to limiting
impact and outcome.
Husbandry practices that occur late in the maturation process are also
important to egg performance. A sliver/brown sort done too early or near
the critical GtH I/II changeover period can result in the undesired
effects. These include sorting, transporting and routine handling
(injections).
Making the best
The doom and gloom scenario of stressors and consequence can be
ameliorated. Obviously, some of the biggest stressors can be avoided by
site selection. Others can be avoided by performing necessary husbandry
operations at the correct times. Generally, for early effects these are
when temperatures are lower and before peak vitellogenesis occurs (i.e.:
before June). For later stressors, the timing for handling and sorting
is as close to spawning as practicality will allow.
From a purely practical standpoint, there is no great time to sort,
select or handle. However, the use of SOPs will help in limiting the
effects of these routine procedures, especially if they are reviewed and
modified from year to year. Another key is to handle using approved
anesthetics and sedatives. These will limit animal stress and in the
case of sedation with Metomidate, block the cortisol response.
|