Comparative studies on Spawning-inducing
Using Ovaprim and other hormones
Xu Pao Min Kuanhong
Zhu Jian Wang Jianxin Gong Yongseng
(Freshwater
Fisheries Research Center, Chinese Academy of Fishery Sciences, Wuxi, China)
Abstract
Ovaprim
and PG, HCG, LRH were concurrently used to induce final maturation and spawning in
freshwater fishes. Trials of five freshwater fish species as mandarin fish, black carp,
silver carp, crucian carp and common carp were conducted. The rice field eel is not be
able for a trial because the climate was abnormal and a serious flood happened affecting
the gonadal in maturation fully. From the data of trials, it is found that the
effectiveness of Ovaprim inducing fish spawning is better than the products used before
and Ovaprim can also induce final maturation, increase milt production and improve the
fecundity greatly. The training is also conducted for marketing
potentials.
Key words: Ovaprim, PG, HCG, LRHa, spawning inducing,
Freshwater Fisheries Research
Center (FFRC) cooperated with Syndel International Inc. Canada on the experiment for fish
hormone product. According to the program, FFRC introduced the Syndel product Ovaprim in
April 1999. The objective of project is to induce final maturation and spawning in high
economic value species or hard to spawn species with Ovaprim and conduct trials to compare
product pituitary gland (PG), human chorionic gonadotropin (HCG), luteinizing (hormone)
releasing hormone analogue (LHRHa, LRHa) made in China with Ovaprim. Six freshwater fish
species, mandarin fish (Siniperca chautsi), black carp (Mylopharyngodon piceus), silver
carp (Hypophthalmichtys molitrix), crucian carp (Carassius carassius), common carp
(Cyprinus carpio) and ricefield eel (Monpterus albus) were selected in the trial.
Experimental targets in our trial involve response time (time from treatment to spawning),
spawning rate, fertilization rate, hatching rate and survival rate, etc.
1 Materials
and methods
1.1 Materials
1.1.1 Mandarin fish (Siniperca chautsi)
Mandarin fish is a famous and
precious freshwater fish with high economic value. Ovaprim is used to induce final
maturation and spawning and the effectiveness is to be compared with other hormone
product.
1.1.2 Black carp (Mylopharyngodon piceus)
The
spawning inducing of black carp is difficult and need a lot of labor and time because the
injection for female is usually twice or even three times. For two injections, the first
one is for promoting maturation, second one is for inducing spawning. Interval between two
injections is about 10 hours. The male black carp is given only one injection at the
second time of the female. For three injections, the first and second are promoting
maturation, the interval is 15days. The third is about 10h after the second for inducing
spawning. For the male fish, one injection is given at the same time the female receives
the last injection. If maturity of the male fish is not achieved, i.e., the sperm cannot
be squeezed out, a double injection method may be adopted. A single injection of Ovaprim
is most often sufficient to induce spawning. It can save manpower and expense.
1.1.3 Crucian carp (Carassius carassius)
Crucian carp is delicious and in
great demand by consumers. It is found that fertilization rate of crucian carp is low,
sometimes even below 10%. It affected the production of fry. The objective of using
Ovaprim is to induce final maturation, increase milt production and improve the
fertilization rate greatly.
1.1.4 Silver carp (Hypophthalmichtys molitrix)
and Common carp (Cyprinus carpio)
Silver carp and Common carp are
the species with very high production. They are the principle food fish in China. The
spawning inducing of silver carp and common carp is relatively easy. The purpose of the
trial is to compare Ovaprim with hormone product made in China.
1.1.5 Ricefield eel (Monpterus albus)
Ricefield eel is a nutritious and
delicious species, it sells well in the market with high economic value. But the spawning
inducing of ricefield eel is not so easy because the sex reversal makes the
differentiation between male and female difficult. The parent fish is captured from field
or brought from market, it is easy to be injured and the survival rate is low. And the
fecundity of female is small, just 200-600 eggs a fish. It is also difficult to get large
quantities of fries. The objective of project is to induce final maturation and spawning
with Ovaprim, and obtain fries with large scale.
1.2
Methods
Table 1. A brief introduction to the trial
|
Species |
Date treated |
Water temp. |
Trial site |
Product used |
|
Mandarin fish |
May, 8th. |
25°C |
Fish farm of Changshu city |
Ovaprim, PG, LRHa |
|
Black carp |
May, 22nd. |
25°C |
Fish farm of Changshu city |
Ovaprim, PG, LRHa |
| Silver carp |
May, 20th. |
22°C |
Fish fry and fingerling farm of Xishan city |
Ovaprim, HCG, LRHa |
|
Crucian carp |
April, 21st. |
18°C |
Experimental fish farm of Wuxi Fisheries Research Institute (FFRC) |
Ovaprim, HCG, LRHa |
|
Common carp |
April, 16th. |
18°C |
Experimental fish farm of FFRC |
Ovaprim, HCG, LRHa |
|
Ricefield eel |
June, 22nd |
26°C |
Experimental fish farm of FFRC |
Ovaprim, LRHa |
1.2.1 Black carp (Mylopharyngodon piceus) and
Silver carp (Hypophthalmichtys molitrix)
Only after a fish reaches sexual
maturity can it be induced to spawn; whether the fish is properly reached or not will
directly affect the results of induced spawning. The rearing of brood fish therefore is an
important step in the artificial propagation of cultured fish.
Induced Spawning
In induced spawning, the mature
parent fish are injected with spawning inducing agents. The basic principle behind induced
spawning comes from the biological mechanism of natural propagation. Because the external
ecological conditions in ponds cannot satisfy the reproductive requirements of the brood
fish, the fish are injected with extraneous hormones. Some extraneous hormones (e.g., PG
and HCG) can take the place of the hormones directly secreted by the pituitary gland of
the parent fish and directly stimulate the gonads. Other extraneous hormones (LRHa) only
stimulate the hypophysis of the parent fish, accelerating the secretion of gonadotrophin
and inducing the parent fish to spawn or discharge milt.
Choosing the most suitable season
to induce spawning is an important step in the artificial propagation. The optimum time
depends on the weather and the gonad development of fish. The initial propagation period
in Guangdong Province is early May; that in Jiangsu and Zhejiang provinces is from the
middle of May to the middle of June. The optimum temperature range is 22-28°C.
Injection
Preparation of
injection
To prepare the PG suspension
fluid, first calculate the required amount of PG based on the total body weight of the
parent fish. Second, place the PG into a mortar (if the PG is preserved in liquid, dry it
on a filter paper for 15 min) and grind thoroughly; add enough normal saline to suspend
PG. The volume of injections should be controlled at 2-3 ml for each parent fish.
When HCG and LRHa are injected,
the required dose must be combined with normal saline at a concentration of 0.7%. When the
powder dissolves, the solution is ready to be injected. It should be prepared right before
use so as to prevent the loss of efficacy.
Method and
frequency of injection
Intraperitoneal injection is
common. There are two frequencies of injection: single and double. For the single
injection, the predetermined dose is completely injected into the fish. For the double
injection, the predetermined dose is divided into two separate dosages and injected twice.
The amount of the first injection is usually 10-20% of the total dose; 90-80% is in the
second injection. Milters always receive only one injection. The injection is given to the
milter when the spawner receives the second injection. The interval between the two
injections is 8-12 hours. Both the single-injection and double-injection techniques give
satisfactory results.
Spawning
Response time
Under normal conditions, there is
a delay from the time of the last injection until the parent fish enter estrus. This
period is called the response time.
Response time vary slightly
depending on water temperature, the spawning inducing agent, the injection frequency, and
the species induced. When the water temperature raise 1°C, the response time decreases
1-2 h. The double-injection method has a shorter response time than the single-injection
method. For example, when the water temperature is 24-25°C and a silver carp is induced
with a single PG injection, the response time is 12-14 h; with the double-
injection
method, the response time is 7-8 h (counted from the second injection). The response time
to PG injection is 1 or 2 h shorter than that to HCG injection; the response time to LRHa
injection is longer than that of PG injection. In addition, given the same hormone at same
dosage during the same season, the response times of various species are slightly
different. Generally, silver carp show the shorter response time than black carp.
Methods of
collecting fertilized eggs
There are two methods of
collecting fertilized eggs. One method involves the addition of slowly flowing water to
the spawning pond during estrus. This helps to bring the gametes together and raise the
fertilization rate. After spawning, the blood fish are removed and the eggs collected by
flushing the pool. The eggs then flow into the egg-collecting cage, where they are
collected and counted. Another method involves pouring water into the pond after spawning
and flushing the fertilized eggs, which sink to the bottom, into the egg-collecting cage.
This is called still-water spawning.
Artificial
Insemination
When the brood fish are in estrus
and begin to spawn, they are immediately captured. Eggs and milt are collected to bring
the mature egg and sperm together. This is called artificial insemination. The eggs
must be at the proper stage of maturity so that after fertilization they will develop
normally. There are two methods of artificial insemination for Chinese carps: the dry
method and the semi-dry method. In the dry method, about 15min after the beginning of
estrus, the brood fish is captured and stripped. The eggs are collected with a basin. The
semen is either directly squeezed onto the eggs or transferred with a pipette and dropped
onto the eggs. The mixture is then stirred gently by hand or with a feather for about 1min
and a little clean water is added. The mixture is stirred again for 1 min, allow to stand
for 1 min, and the dirty water is then removed. After the eggs have been washed 3 times in
this way, they are transferred to an incubator. In semi-dry method, the semen is diluted
with a little normal saline and transferred onto the eggs by pipette. Otherwise, this
technique is as the dry method.
Incubation
Incubation not only involves
bringing the eggs through embryonic development to hatching out but also includes all the
management work from hatching to stocking ponds. The hatching instrument of black carp and
silver carp is raceway or hatch jar.
The eggs of Chinese carps are
semibuoyant. After the eggs have been fertilized and have absorbed water, the egg membrane
expends to about 5-6 mm in diameter. In stagnant water, the eggs sink; in running water,
they float. In rivers, fertilized eggs will float and hatch. The embryonic development is
closely dependent upon environmental conditions: e.g., oxygen supply, water temperature,
and water current.
For normal embryonic development
and hatching of Chinese carp the water temperature must range from 17°C to 30°C. The optimum range is 25-27°C. As water
temperature increases, the speed of embryonic development also increases.
1.2.2 Common carp (Cyprinus carpio)
A month before spawning, the
female and male parent fish should be reared separately in order to keep the breeders
spawning in the meantime.
The initial artificial
reproduction age of female and male parent fish should be 3 years and 2 years
respectively. The weight of female and male parent fish should be more than 1.5 and 1 kg.
Artificial inducing and natural
pond spawning can be used in common carp spawning.
Spawning inducing could improve
spawning effectiveness and obtain strong fry groups. Spawning inducing agents are PG, HCG
and LRHa. Dosage for female (1kg body weight) is HCG 500-600IU + LRHa 10-20 µg, or LRHa 10-20 µg + PG 2-4 mg,
or PG 4-6 mg, ovaprim 0.5ml, dosage for male is the half of female. Intraperitoneal
injection is common.
The female to male ratio of common
carp stocked in spawning pond should be 1:1-1:1.5. Water temperature of natural spawning
is 16-18°C. The response time from injection to parent fish entering estrus is 20-24
hours. After fertilized eggs stuck to palm fiber, move the palms to fry-rearing pond.
At 20°C, the fertilized eggs of
common carp take 101-104 hours to incubate; at 25°C, 49-53 h. Generally speaking,
hatching of fertilized eggs need 4-5 days at the water temperature of 18-20°C. The eggs
hatching can also be conducted in running water system, such as hatching jar and hatching
circulator.
1.2.3 Crucian carp (Carassius carassius)
The artificial propagation of
crucian carp is similar to common carp. Crucian carp begins to spawning when the water
temperature reaches 18°C, in middle April to May in Changjiang River drainage, a little
later than common carp. The optimum spawning temperature is 20-22°C. The initial
artificial reproduction age of parent fish is 2 years. The weight of female parent fish
should be more than 300g and male 250g. The quantity of male crucian carp is usually less
than the female, so the female to male ratio of artificial propagation is 2-3:1. Crucian
carp can use artificial induced spawning and natural pond hatching. Spawning inducing
agents and dosage refer to common carp.
1.2.4 Mandarin fish (Siniperca chautsi)
Artificial inducing and natural
raceway spawning can be used in mandarin fish.
Spawning inducing agents are PG,
HCG and LRHa. Dosage for female (1kg body weight) is HCG 1500IU + LRHa 150 µg, or LRHa
50-100 µg + PG 5-8 mg, or PG 5 mg +HCG 500IU + LRHa 50 µg, or ovaprim 0.5ml, dosage for
male is the half of female.
The female to male ratio of
mandarin fish stocked in spawning pond should be 1:1-1:1.5. Water temperature of natural
spawning is 25-28°C. The response time from injection to parent fish entering estrus is
24-35 hours.
At 25-30°C, the fertilized eggs
of mandarin fish take 30-50 hours to incubate. The eggs hatching usually conducts in
running water system, such as hatching jar and hatching circulator.
1.2.5 Ricefield eel (Monpterus albus)
Artificial propagation of
ricefield eel is similar to black carp and silver carp. But more parent fish is needed
because the fecundity of female is small, just 200-600 eggs a fish.
Artificial inducing and natural
pond spawning can be used in common carp spawning.
Spawning inducing agents are PG,
HCG or LRHA. For dosage, there is an example in the table. The dosage in the table is for
one injection separately.
Table 2. The
spawning inducing dose of ricefield eel.
|
HCG |
LRHa |
PG |
|
Weight (g) |
Dose (IU) |
Weight (g) |
Dose (µg) |
Weight (g) |
Dose (mg) |
| Female |
75-250 |
150-600 |
75-250 |
5-15 |
75-250 |
2-3 |
| Male |
120-300 |
200-400 |
120-300 |
15-20 |
120-300 |
2-4 |
*Ovaprim: 0.5ml/kg for female,
0.25ml/kg for male.
The female to male ratio of
ricefield eel stocked should be 1:1-1:3. Water temperature of natural spawning is
25-28°C. The response time from injection to parent fish entering estrus is 40-75 hours.
Artificial insemination is common in the artificial spawning inducing.
At 25-28°C, the fertilized eggs
of ricefield eel take 5-7 days to incubate. The eggs hatching can be conducted in glass
jar, small cage, etc.
1.3. Spawning Inducing Agents
1.3.1 LRHa
The secretion activities of the
hypophysis are directly controlled by the hypothalamus, which secretes LRH. In China, LRH
was refined from the hypothalamus of sheep in 1971. Analysis showed LRH to be peptide of
10 aminoacids; pyroglutamic acid, histidine, tryptophan, serine, tyrosine, glutamic acid,
leucine, arginine, groline, and glycine amide. Its molecular weight is 1182. Artificial
synthesized LRH has a high biological activity for cows, sheep, and humans. When it is
used to induce spawning in fish, however, the dose must be 100 times higher than that for
mammals because LRH is easily destroyed by fish protease. In 1975, LRHa was synthesized.
This analogue of LRH consist of nine amino acids (pyroglutamic acid, histidine, trytophan,
serine, tyrosine, D-alanine, leucine, arginine, and proline) and acetyl amine. Its
molecular weight is 1167. The 6th (glutamic acid) and the 10th (glycine amide) amino acids
of LRH are replaced by D-alanine and acetyl amine in LRHa. The biological activity of LRHa
is about 100 times higher than that of LRH to fish. The LRHa available on the market is a
white powder and is combined with mannite as a filler. It is soluble in water and should
be stored in a dry, shady, airtight-environment.
LRHa can be used for one
injection. Two consecutive injections are more effective. If LRHa is used in combination
with HCG or PG, it stimulates the ova to mature or promotes the polarization of nucleus
and the rate of successful induction is high and constant.
1.3.2 Common carp pituitary gland (PG)
The pituitary gland, or the
hypophysis, lies beneath the diencephalon, connecting with the hypothalamus. When the
fish's brain is lifted upside down, the PG is easily separated from the hypothalamus. It
is buried in the sphenoid. The hypophysis excretes two gonadotrophic hormones: LH, which
stimulates ovulation, and FSH, which promotes the development and maturity of the eggs and
stimulates the development and maturity of the follicles. The estrus-inducing effect of PG
on Chinese carps is immediately evident.
Hypophysis can be collected from
mature male or female common carp weighing more than 0.5 kg. It can also be collected from
dead, unspoiled fish. The hypophysis of a common carp that has never spawned is the best.
To remove the hypophysis, first, cut off the head of the fish, set the head on its cut
surface with the snout facing upward, and use a knife to cut from the nostrils to the
upper edge of the eyes and remove the front parietal bone. Turn the whole brain upside
down with a pair of forceps and the hypophsis can be removed.
If fresh hypophysis is used, it
should be ground before use or dehydrated and defatted with pure acetone or absolute
alcohol(use a volume about 15-20 times that of the hypophysis). The hypophysis can be
preserved for future use after the acetone or alcohol has been renewed twice (immersed for
1-2 h each time). There are methods of preservation. First, the dehydrated hypophysis is
dried on a piece of filter paper for 15-20 min and then stored in a tightly sealed,
labeled small brown bottle. Second, the hypophysis is left in the second immersion liquid
and stored in a tightly sealed, labeled small brown bottle. Both methods give good
results. Generally, the hypophysis is still effective after 2 years of preservation.
1.3.3 Human chorionic gonadotropin (HCG)
Human chorionic gonadotropin is a
polypeptide hormone. Its molecular weight is 36,000. In physiological function, it is
similar to LH and FSH. It promotes ovulation, gonad development, and sex-hormone
secretion. The hormone is refined from the urine of women who are 2-4 months pregnant. It
is secreted from the chorionic membrane of the placenta. At present, the ready-made
material available on the market in China is "veterinary gonadotropin." It is a
white powder that is soluble in water and must be stored in a cool, shady, dry, airtight
environment.
1.3.4 Ovaprim
Ovaprim contains Syndel's patented
analogue of salmon GnRH (SGnRHa) and domperidone, a dopamine inhibitor, in a sterile
liquid for easy injection. SGnRHa works with the natural spawning system of the fish. When
injected, it causes the release of natural hormones in the fish brain and gonads to
trigger normal spawning and spermiation. SgnRHa is more potent and consistent than any
other available spawning product. Domperidone blocks the negative effects of dopamine that
normally inhibits hormone release. In hard-to-spawn fish, domperidone is essential to
support the effectiveness of SgnRHa. Domperidone is safer and more effective than other
available Dopamine inhibitors. Ovaprim must be used during, or at the start of the
spawning season. Accurate records of spawning dates and performance of the fish population
are required. A single injection of Ovaprim is most often sufficient to induce spawning.
2 Results
Ovaprim is a liquid product
different with HCG, LRHa and PG, it needn't to be dissolved and prepared. It is used for
injection directly and easily. The dose for injection is treated accurately.
The effectiveness of Ovaprim
inducing fish spawning is better than the control products. It is found that the response
time of Ovaprim is one hour longer than the control. The results of the five species are
given below, the detailed data could be seen in the clinical field study reporting forms
drafted afterwards.
2.1 Mandarin fish
Table 3. Result
of mandarin fish.
|
No. of treatment |
Dosage of hormone |
Results |
|
|
|
Female |
Male |
Fer.% |
Hat.% |
| Ovaprim |
16 |
20 |
0.5 ml/kg |
0.25 ml/kg |
80% |
78% |
| The control |
16 |
20 |
PG 2.5mg + LRHa 50µg/kg |
PG 1.25mg + LRHa 25µg/kg |
76% |
75% |
Fer.%: fertilization rate. Hat.%: hatching rate.
2.2 Black carp
The injection for female black
carp is usually twice, the first one for promoting maturation, second one for inducing
spawning. The dosage of the first time usually is one-tenth of the second. Interval
between two injections is about 10 hours. The male black carp is given only one injection
at the second time of the female.
Table 4. Result
of black carp.
|
|
No. of treatment |
Dosage of hormone |
Results |
|
|
|
|
Female |
Male |
Fer.% |
Hat.% |
| Ovaprim |
10 |
12 |
1)0.5ml/fish
2)5ml/fish |
5 ml/fish |
90% |
70% |
| The control |
10 |
12 |
1)LRHa 2µg/kg
2)PG
2mg + LRHa 20µg/kg |
PG 1mg + LRHa 10 µg/kg |
85% |
65% |
2.3
Silver
carp
Table 5. Result
of silver carp.
|
|
No. of treatment |
Dosage of hormone |
Results |
|
|
|
|
Female |
Male |
Fer.% |
Hat.% |
| Ovaprim |
12 |
18 |
0.5 ml/kg |
0.25 ml/kg |
85% |
90% |
| The control |
12 |
18 |
HCG 200IU +LRHa 28µg/kg |
HCG 100IU+ LRHa 14µg/kg |
80% |
85% |
2.4 Crucian carp
Ovaprim can induce final
maturation, increase milt production and improve the fecundity greatly.
Table 6. Result
of crucian carp.
|
|
No. of treatment |
Dosage of hormone |
Results |
|
|
|
|
Female |
Male |
Fer.% |
Hat.% |
| Ovaprim |
150 |
120 |
0.5 ml/kg |
0.25 ml/kg |
40% |
60% |
| The control |
300 |
240 |
HCG 500-600IU +LRHa 50µg/kg |
HCG 250-300IU +LRHa 25µg/kg |
10% |
60% |
2.5
Common carp
Table 7. Result
of common carp.
|
|
No. of treatment |
Dosage of hormone |
Results |
|
|
|
|
Female |
Male |
Fer.% |
Hat.% |
| Ovaprim |
30 |
40 |
0.5 ml/kg |
0.25 ml/kg |
90% |
75% |
| The control |
100 |
150 |
HCG 400IU +LRHa 20µg/kg |
HCG 200IU+ LRHa 10µg/kg |
80% |
70% |
2.6 Ricefield eel
Table. 8 The
dosage of hormone treated in ricefield eel
|
|
No. of treatment |
|
Dosage of hormone |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Female |
Male |
| Ovaprim |
10 |
10 |
100 |
200 |
0.5 ml/kg |
0.25 ml/kg |
| The control |
10 |
10 |
100 |
200 |
LRHa 15µg/fish |
LRHa 20µg/fish |
The climate in Wuxi this year is
abnormal. A big flood occurred and the temperature is lower than usual. Low temperature
and continuous cloudy and rainy day affected the maturity of parent fish and survival
rate. The spawning inducing of ricefield eel wasn't successful and the parent fish didn't
spawn normally. We plan to do the trial again next year and then we will get some
effective data then.
|